Is Bitcoin More Energy Intensive Than Mainstream Finance?

Is Bitcoin More Energy Intensive Than Mainstream Finance?
Fix, Blair. (2024). Economics from the Top Down. 21 March. pp. 1-25. (Article - Magazine; English).

Full Text Available As:

Preview	Cover Image 20240321_fix_is_bitcoin_more_energy_intensive_front.jpg Download (398kB) | Preview
Preview	PDF (Full text) 20240321_fix_is_bitcoin_more_energy_intensive.pdf Download (4MB) | Preview
	HTML (Full text) 20240321_fix_is_bitcoin_more_energy_intensive.html Download (222kB)
	Other (Full text -- EPub) 20240321_fix_is_bitcoin_more_energy_intensive.epub Download (6MB)

Alternative Locations

https://economicsfromthetopdown.com/2024/03/21/is-bitcoin-more-energy-intensive-than-mainstream-finance/, https://yorkspace.library.yorku.ca/items/7711e729-42a1-4a8d-8192-056104693516, https://www.econstor.eu/handle/10419/289512

Abstract or Brief Description

When it comes to Bitcoin, there’s one thing that almost everyone agrees on: the network sucks up a tremendous amount of energy. But from there, disagreement is the rule.

For critics, Bitcoin’s thirst for energy is self-evidently bad — the equivalent of pouring gasoline in a hole and setting it on fire. But for Bitcoin advocates, the network’s energy gluttony is the necessary price of having a secure digital currency. When judging Bitcoin’s energy demands, the advocates continue, keep in mind that mainstream finance is itself no model of efficiency.

Here, I think the advocates have a point.

If you want to argue that Bitcoin is an energy hog, you’ve got to do more than just point at its energy budget and say ‘bad’. You’ve got to show that this budget is worse than mainstream finance.

On this comparison front, there seems to be a vacuum of good information. For their part, crypto promoters are happy to show that Bitcoin uses less energy than the global banking system. But this result is as unsurprising as it is meaningless. Compared to Bitcoin, global finance operates on a vastly larger scale. So of course it uses more energy.

To be meaningful, any comparison between Bitcoin and mainstream finance must account for the different scales of the two systems. So instead of looking at energy alone, we need to look at energy intensity — the energy per unit of circulating currency. That’s what I’ll do here. In this post, I compare the energy intensity of Bitcoin to the energy intensity of mainstream US finance.

Which system comes out on top? The results may surprise you.

Language

English

Publication Type

Article - Magazine

Keywords

bitcoin energy finance

Subject

BN Money & Finance
BN Region - North America
BN Science & Technology
BN Value & Price
BN Business Enterprise
BN Ecology & Environment
BN Institutions

Depositing User

Jonathan Nitzan

Date Deposited

26 Mar 2024 23:23

Last Modified

12 Apr 2024 00:39

URL:

https://bnarchives.yorku.ca/id/eprint/825

Actions (login required)

View Item